The U.S. national debt has grown to unprecedented levels, raising questions about fiscal sustainability, intergenerational equity, and appropriate government spending and taxation levels. Debates center on whether debt levels are dangerous, how to address deficits, and the proper role of government in the economy.
Below are the major policy positions on this issue, arranged from one end of the spectrum to the other.
MMT argues that federal debt is simply the private sector's savings and that inflation, not debt levels, should be the constraint on spending. Deficits enable private sector surplus.
Example: COVID-era spending without corresponding tax increases demonstrated capacity for large deficits.
Argues that not all debt is equal - borrowing for productive investment pays for itself through growth. Austerity during economic weakness is counterproductive.
Example: Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (2021), Inflation Reduction Act investments.
Acknowledges debt is a problem but requires balanced solution. Neither spending cuts alone nor tax increases alone can solve the problem.
Example: Simpson-Bowles Commission recommendations (2010), never fully implemented.
Argues that the U.S. has a spending problem, not a revenue problem. Reducing government size will boost economic growth and freedom.
Example: Republican budget proposals, 2011 Budget Control Act spending caps.
Based on belief that lower taxes increase economic activity sufficiently to maintain or increase revenue (Laffer Curve). Prioritizes growth over short-term deficit concerns.
Example: 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act; Reagan-era tax cuts.
Views current debt trajectory as unsustainable and potentially catastrophic. Willing to accept short-term pain for long-term stability.
Example: European austerity measures post-2008; U.S. sequestration (2013).
How other nations approach this issue:
Highest debt-to-GDP ratio among developed nations (~260%) but continues to borrow at low rates. Most debt held domestically. Demonstrates that high debt doesn't automatically cause crisis. Policies: Massive government debt; Bank of Japan bond purchases; low interest rates Statistics: Debt-to-GDP: ~260%. No debt crisis despite predictions. Aging population drives spending. Outcomes: Stable despite high debt due to domestic ownership, current account surplus, and monetary policy.
Constitutional 'debt brake' limits structural deficits. Fiscally conservative approach prioritizes balanced budgets. Recently loosened for defense spending. Policies: Schuldenbremse (debt brake); structural deficit limit of 0.35% GDP Statistics: Debt-to-GDP: ~66%. Budget surplus in some years pre-COVID. Outcomes: Low debt but criticized for under-investment in infrastructure. Some easing post-Ukraine invasion.
Debt crisis (2010-2018) required multiple bailouts and severe austerity. Example of what happens when debt becomes unsustainable without currency sovereignty. Policies: EU/IMF bailouts; severe austerity; pension/wage cuts; privatization Statistics: Debt-to-GDP peaked over 180%. GDP fell 25%. Unemployment reached 27%. Outcomes: Cautionary tale about eurozone debt. Austerity caused major economic and social damage.
Post-2010 austerity program cut spending significantly. Recent Truss government's unfunded tax cuts caused market crisis (2022). Balancing act between fiscal restraint and investment. Policies: Austerity 2010-2019; spending increases post-COVID; fiscal rules Statistics: Debt-to-GDP: ~100%. Austerity cut public services significantly. Outcomes: Austerity controversial - some argue it slowed recovery and harmed public services.
Significant deficit reduction in 1990s through spending cuts. Maintained relatively strong fiscal position. Recent deficits for COVID and housing. Policies: 1990s deficit elimination; more recent deficits for stimulus Statistics: Debt-to-GDP: ~107% (federal+provincial). Strong recovery from 1990s fiscal crisis. Outcomes: 1990s reforms seen as successful model for deficit reduction without economic collapse.
Consistent budget surpluses and massive sovereign wealth accumulation. Conservative fiscal approach with low debt. Policies: Budget surpluses; sovereign wealth funds; low taxes but high savings Statistics: Net creditor nation. Temasek and GIC sovereign wealth funds among world's largest. Outcomes: Exceptional fiscal position but unique circumstances (small, wealthy city-state).
Get weekly policy updates and new issue alerts delivered to your inbox.
Taxation policy determines how governments raise revenue to fund public services and programs. Debates center on the appropriate level of taxation, who should bear the tax burden, the balance between income and consumption taxes, and how tax policy affects economic growth, investment, and inequality. The U.S. employs a mix of progressive income taxes, payroll taxes, corporate taxes, and various state and local taxes.